Bidding Summary Report
Location: Banteay Meanchey Budget Year: 2008
| Commune | Contract ID | Bid Date | # Of Bidders | # Valid Bidders | Qty Changed | Award To | Contract Value | Bidding Detail | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name | Bid Value | Rejected | Note | ||||||||
| District: [102] Mongkol Borei | |||||||||||
| Banteay Neang | 010201/08/01 | 25-Mar-2008 | 6 | 6 | Yes | Lao Bunna [ Lao Bunna ] | 56,824,692 | Lao Bunna [ Lao Bunna ] | 62,945,000 | No | Lowest bid price but higher estimated cost (winner) |
| Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 68,199,000 | No | Invalid because errio in sum and in multiply | ||||||||
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 70,203,364 | No | Has validity but too high bid price | ||||||||
| Prak Sarak [ Sroeun Sokha ] | 71,128,400 | No | Has validity but too high bid pricr | ||||||||
| Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 71,181,880 | No | Has not vilidity due to no unit price and sub total price | ||||||||
| Liv Sokun [ Liv Sokun ] | 73,909,360 | No | higher estimated cost and bid form is invalid due to no unit price and sub total price | ||||||||
| Chamnaom | 010203/08/01 | 24-Jun-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 53,527,700 | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 55,449,700 | No | Valid, lowest bid price-acceptable |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 58,854,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Lao Bunna [ Lao Bunna ] | 60,008,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Kouk Ballangk | 010204/08/01 | 24-Jun-2008 | 5 | 5 | No | Chea Sang [ Chea Sang ] | 71,728,000 | Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 69,842,000 | No | Invalid by error in multiplying of first ouput |
| District: [103] Phnum Srok | |||||||||||
| Nam Tau | 010301/08/01 | 29-Apr-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 42,920,240 | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 45,158,000 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 48,788,000 | No | Bid price too high and not accepted | ||||||||
| Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 50,940,000 | No | Highest bid price and not accepted | ||||||||
| Paoy Char | 010302/08/02 | 02-Jul-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 47,719,176 | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 46,999,999 | No | The lowest bid price - acceptable |
| Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 48,810,000 | No | Too high bid price-unacceptable | ||||||||
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 52,820,000 | No | Too high bid price-unacceptable | ||||||||
| Ponley | 010303/08/01 | 08-Aug-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 84,696,800 | Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 81,756,800 | No | The lowest bid price - acceptable |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 81,901,036 | No | Too high bid price-unacceptable | ||||||||
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 82,279,800 | No | Too high bid price-unacceptable | ||||||||
| Spean Sraeng | 010304/08/01 | 02-Jul-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 22,250,000 | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 25,000,000 | No | Valid, lowest bid preice -acceptable |
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 26,000,000 | No | Valid, high bid price- not acceptable | ||||||||
| Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 26,528,000 | No | Valid, high bid price- not acceptable | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 26,528,000 | No | Valid, high bid price- not acceptable | ||||||||
| Spean Sraeng | 010304/08/02 | 29-Apr-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 37,464,286 | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 35,000,000 | No | Valid - lowest bid price (winner) |
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 39,088,000 | No | Valid - too hight price,not acceptable | ||||||||
| Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 39,275,000 | No | Valid - too hight price,not acceptable | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 39,912,000 | No | Valid - too hight price,not acceptable | ||||||||
| Srah Chik | 010305/08/01 | 02-Jul-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 32,480,000 | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 28,000,000 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 28,920,000 | No | First lower bid price | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 32,617,200 | No | Highest bid price | ||||||||
| Srah Chik | 010305/08/02 | 23-Jun-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Brok Toeung [ Brok Toeung ] | 35,535,201 | Brok Toeung [ Brok Toeung ] | 37,214,749 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 38,434,122 | No | High bid price and not accepted | ||||||||
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 39,491,912 | No | High bid price and not accepted | ||||||||
| Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 40,549,776 | No | Highest bid price and not accepted | ||||||||
| Phnum Dei | 010306/08/01 | 02-Jul-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 33,977,406 | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 35,668,350 | No | Valid, lowest bid price-acceptable |
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 36,922,500 | No | Valid, high bid price- not acceptable | ||||||||
| Brok Toeung [ Brok Toeung ] | 37,462,500 | No | Valid, high bid price- not acceptable | ||||||||
| Phnum Dei | 010306/08/02 | 02-Jul-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 39,335,430 | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 42,384,384 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 44,060,000 | No | High bid price and not accepted | ||||||||
| Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 46,480,000 | No | Highest bid price and not accepted | ||||||||
| District: [104] Preah Netr Preah | |||||||||||
| Chhnuor Mean Chey | 010401/08/01 | 06-May-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 40,559,616 | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 51,840,000 | No | Bid price is higher estimated cost but lowest price (winner) |
| Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 52,650,000 | No | Firth higher bid price | ||||||||
| LAM CHHEUN [ LAM CHHEUN ] | 54,945,000 | No | Second higher bid price | ||||||||
| Phnum Lieb | 010403/08/01 | 06-May-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 93,275,640 | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 110,000,000 | No | Lowest bid price but higher estimated cost (Winner) |
| LAM CHHEUN [ LAM CHHEUN ] | 111,000,000 | No | Second higher bid price | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 134,487,000 | No | Third higher bid price | ||||||||
| Preah Netr Preah | 010405/08/01 | 20-Jun-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Khem Taily [ Khem Taily ] | 46,274,700 | Khem Taily [ Khem Taily ] | 47,523,000 | No | Valid, lowest bid preice-acceptable |
| Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 54,250,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 54,250,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Rohal | 010406/08/01 | 20-Jun-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 40,300,000 | Sueng Seu [ Sueng Seu ] | 39,400,000 | No | The lowest bid price - acceptable |
| Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 40,180,500 | No | Too high bid price - not acceptable | ||||||||
| Khem Taily [ Khem Taily ] | 40,410,000 | No | Too high bid price - not acceptable | ||||||||
| District: [105] Ou Chrov | |||||||||||
| Kuttasat | 010503/08/01 | 01-Jul-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 32,527,240 | Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 34,988,500 | No | Valid, lowest bid price-acceptable |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 41,500,000 | No | Valid, too high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 43,000,000 | No | Valid, too high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 44,500,000 | No | Valid, too high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Samraong | 010505/08/01 | 01-Jul-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 69,396,563 | Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 73,800,000 | No | Valid, lowest bid price-acceptable |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 75,000,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 78,500,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 81,000,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Soengh | 010507/08/01 | 10-Jul-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 51,954,750 | Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 54,954,750 | No | Valid, lowest bid price-acceptable |
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 55,511,250 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 55,867,970 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| District: [106] Serei Saophoan | |||||||||||
| Bos Sbov | 010601/08/01 | 30-Jun-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 83,036,500 | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 95,495,000 | No | Valid, lowest bid price-acceptable |
| Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 99,362,500 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 101,000,000 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Kampong Svay | 010602/08/01 | 16-Jun-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 56,630,550 | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 58,865,250 | No | Lowest bid brice-acceptable |
| LAM CHHEUN [ LAM CHHEUN ] | 63,129,800 | No | First higher bid price | ||||||||
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 64,636,300 | No | Second higher bid price | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 65,232,800 | No | Third higher bid price | ||||||||
| Kaoh Pong Satv | 010603/08/01 | 30-Jun-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 76,190,370 | Pov Thy [ Prom Rithy ] | 79,362,970 | No | Valid, lowest bid price-accaptable |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 79,470,472 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 79,473,475 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 90,823,371 | No | Valid, high bid price-not acceptable | ||||||||
| Mkak | 010604/08/01 | 16-Jun-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 68,302,000 | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 71,062,000 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 72,750,000 | No | Second higher bid price | ||||||||
| Khenh Kagnanak [ Khenh Kagnanak ] | 73,040,000 | No | Third higher bid price | ||||||||
| LAM CHHEUN [ LAM CHHEUN ] | 73,794,000 | No | Fourth higher bid price | ||||||||
| Ou Ambel | 010605/08/01 | 07-May-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 51,099,200 | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 63,786,800 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 64,800,000 | No | Higher estimated cost | ||||||||
| Sem Muon [ Sem Muon ] | 64,957,200 | No | Higher estimated cost | ||||||||
| Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 65,200,000 | No | Highest bid price | ||||||||
| Tuek Thla | 010608/08/01 | 07-May-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 44,044,000 | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 54,756,000 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| Sem Muon [ Sem Muon ] | 55,071,900 | No | Higher estimarted cost | ||||||||
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 57,000,000 | No | Higher estimated cost | ||||||||
| Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 57,236,000 | No | Highest bid price | ||||||||
| District: [107] Thma Puok | |||||||||||
| Phum Thmei | 010703/08/01 | 16-Jun-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | LAM CHHEUN [ LAM CHHEUN ] | 36,696,631 | LAM CHHEUN [ LAM CHHEUN ] | 43,554,000 | No | Lowest bid price but higher estimated cost (winner) |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 45,368,400 | No | Second higher bid price | ||||||||
| Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 45,640,000 | No | Highest bid price | ||||||||
| Kouk Kakthen | 010705/08/01 | 16-Jun-2008 | 3 | 3 | Yes | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 35,118,897 | Hourt Tuch [ Hourt Tuch ] | 41,488,500 | No | Lowest bid price (winner) |
| LAM CHHEUN [ LAM CHHEUN ] | 43,564,200 | No | Too high bid price | ||||||||
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 44,880,000 | No | Too high bid price | ||||||||
| District: [108] Svay Chek | |||||||||||
| Treas | 010807/08/01 | 13-Jun-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 77,947,127 | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 82,600,000 | No | Higher estimated cost but lowest bid price (winner) |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 92,339,500 | No | Third higher bid price | ||||||||
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 94,132,500 | No | Forth higher bid price | ||||||||
| Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 94,939,350 | No | Second higher bid price | ||||||||
| Roluos | 010808/08/01 | 13-Jun-2008 | 4 | 4 | Yes | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 31,963,636 | Uy Phlorn [ Uy Phlorn ] | 34,000,000 | No | Lowest bid price but higher estimated cost (winner) |
| SAR SONG [ SAR SONG ] | 37,699,200 | No | Second high bid price | ||||||||
| Narith Group [ Bun Narith ] | 38,755,750 | No | Third higher bid price | ||||||||
| Ky Chhoeurng [ Ky Chhoeurng ] | 39,223,250 | No | Forth higher bid price | ||||||||
# Of Bidders: number of contractor submit their bid for the specific contract.
# Valid Bidders: number of contractor accepted by the bidding committee.
Rejected: Yes if the bidding committee reject contractor bidding request.